GTD Time-Lapse

In the beginning, I was disorganized, no GTD, no Evernote, no OmniFocus, no Dropbox, no OneNote. My desk looked like this:


Then I went from no GTD to GTD via Paper and Evernote:

My desk changed to this:

Then, I got really excited, and went to a 100% digital GTD system via Omnifocus:

This is the first time I fell off the GTD wagon. I could not stand to sit down at my desk. The feeling of drowning by binary proxy kept me out of my organized office and away from my organized desk. Ugh! But the seeds of were born. Somewhere I’m POSITIVE I heard (via Audible copies of his books) David Allen say “If you get too organized, your brain will refuse to use your system.”

I refactored, cut back the role of Omnifocus, got a new job, Evernoted/digitized the 94,000 pages of notes I had from my Ph.D. and went to a hybrid paper and digital system that looked like this:

And my four desks looked like this:

TrustedSystemgenerations01_pptx 6

Then as I experimented with my system and changed jobs I :

  • Dropped Dropbox for Google drive when I bought a ChromeBook. Google drive is not even in the same league as Dropbox as far as reliability goes, but I’ve stayed with Google drive and Google Apps for simplicity’s sake.
  • Added OneNote to keep work notes separate from home notes. This has actually facilitated manila folders as OneNote makes it *trivial* to print all my tabs (virtual manila folders) and put them into real labeled GTD manila folders.
  • Kept 3×5 cards. They are indispensable for organizing. Laying a large number of cards out on a big table, then re-arranging them into thematic clumps, is the most powerful project organization tool that I possess. *Note* to OneNote and Evernote folks, please please please add 3×5 cards and a flexible user interface for re-arranging cards to your programs!!!!!
  • Kept manila folders. In my new job, I can see my boss relax when I pull out a folder that has an updated project plan in it. And once she saw that she could look in one place for my project list and see what is going on, again, I could visibly see her relax.
  • Kept eMail.

So my system now looks like this:

And my dungeon desk looks like this:

Thoughts on Tools:

  • OmniFocus is an awesome tool. If you are going to implement GTD to the letter, I don’t think there is a better software package. But I learned that implementing GTD to the letter is not for my brain. But there is TREMENDOUS power in OmniFocus if it is for you.
  • Evernote has been with me since the beginning of my GTD journey. I remember listening to David Allen say “the lack of a good general-reference system can be one of the greatest obstacles to implementing a personal management system” (p. 95 Kindle L1500) and realizing “Evernote! I can use Evernote to be my reference filing system!” You see I had Evernote before I read GTD, I just did not have a use model for it, because I did not appreciate how critical reference filing is to GTD.
  • Evernote keeps adding tools. Some of them are wonky (Evernote Hello for example), but Web ClipperClearly, and Skitch have been game changers for me. Evernote has also gradually increased the kinds of files that it indexes (Word for example was a pain before Evernote started indexing it), and the handwriting recognition is slowly improving. The growth of Evernote’s tool set has kept me loyal as I know I don’t need to jump ship for the latest slick tool. Probably, this reticence kept me for too long from trying OneNote again. I was on the beta team for OneNote 1.0 and getting a change made to the program was like trying to teach a pig to sing.
  • Dropbox is also an awesome tool. But it was (a) too expensive and (b) to focused on single users, at the time I adopted it. Dropbox too is adding tools, but unlike Evernote, Dropbox has not added tools at the point of most intense need for me, and built out from there. I’m sure to Dropbox, Evernote’s file replication must look plebeian, a pale copy of Dropbox with a different user interface. But to me, Dropbox is infrastructure first, and OneNote and Evernote are tools first, with backing infrastructure.
  • OneNote has surprised me. The community of kindred minds around OneNote is much larger than Evernote. And OneNote has the same wonderful enthusiasm of Apple products and Evernote, among its users. OneNote has many of the same over-structured limits as Evernote, only 1 level of sub folders, for example. But, the user interface and the integration with Microsoft Office are freeing to my mind. And, I can’t wait to investigate OneNote add-ins. Evernote’s add-ins are a pallid picture of the promise of its API. More on OneNote as I delve deeper.
  • Google Apps and Google Drive have converted me. I’m now keeping my evolving documents (like resume) on Google drive. I’ve had to delete and re-download my stored files three times. And when I look into my Google Drive folders now, I’m often missing files, finding renamed folders that indicate Google Drive has a problem with becoming confused. Dropbox has none of these issues. So I do miss being able to have confidence in my cloud storage. But I’m careful, back up A LOT, and limp through.
  • Google Now. Another fun surprise. Google now reads my emails and then puts notifications on my phone and in my web browser automatically. This is a huge help for my absent mindedness (call me “Dr. Spaz” please).

Where GTDers are on our own.

David Allen does not recommend technology. Technology is too fad-y I suspect. So we are on our own in sharing experiences and frustrations. And, in dealign with providers like Evernote and MicroSoft and OmniGroup in advocating for GTD-helpful features.

GTDers are also on our own figuring out how to separate work and personal trusted systems. “When you’re trying to make a living there ain’t no such thing as pride.” Richard Marx - Don’t Mean Nothing Lyrics | MetroLyrics. And when you are in the middle or the bottom of a big company, keeping separate personal and work trusted system is a key survival skill.

20 thoughts on “GTD Time-Lapse

  1. Pingback: 3×5 Cool Tool | Get (back) on the GTD band wagon!

  2. Pingback: Evernote Biggies | Get (back) on the GTD band wagon!

  3. Pingback: Quick Index of Most-Read Posts | Get (back) on the GTD band wagon!

  4. Pingback: Number 3 Reason GTDers Don’t Use Evernote … after installing Evernote | RestartGTD

  5. Pingback: GTD: Before and After | RestartGTD

  6. Pingback: Quick Index of Most Read Posts | RestartGTD

  7. Similar experience with Bill. Tried so many apps to implement GTD - Things, ToDo, Todoist, IQTell, AnyDo, Omnifocus. But I finally found peace of mind when I settled for paper-based organisers for organising my lists and Evernote/One Note for general reference. When setting reminders of things to do for myself, I want to be done as quick as possible without the need to think or learn how to work arround the digital to do list managers

    • When I open a folder that has an accumulation of 3×5 cards in it, my mind goes “aaaaaahhhhhhhh.” 3×5 cards are certainly higher bandwidth for me than and of the programs that attempt to emulate them. Whatever works for the brain is what counts. Too organized = disorganized and it is easy to get too organized with apps. Then you discover after 3 weeks you are not using the app even though it seems more perfect.

  8. Pingback: Getting Started with GETTING THINGS DONE - 2014 - in 27 steps | RestartGTD

  9. Pingback: Finished BOYS IN THE BOAT | RestartGTD

  10. I’m surprised given your love of 3×5 and free-form index re-organization that you haven’t mentioned or tried Scrivener. Talk about a game-changer! Worth looking at on the slim chance you haven’t already.

    • I have Scrivener and have tried twice to cut over to it. But Scrivener’s workflow was so narrowly focused on writing research papers, I could not get my head around using in in a way like Evernote for reference filing. Also, Scrivener like all the other programs that do electronic cards I’ve seen to date, rigidly locks cards into rows and columns. Just not close enough to the 3×5 experience for me. Analog 3×5 is still far superior to any electronic card programs in my opinion.

  11. If you’re looking for a tool to support your index card style of organizing, give Trello a try.

    • John,

      Thank you for the comment. I’ve signed up for Trello. I think the idea of having cards with notes + files in them + grouping of cards into thematic clumps is way powerful. This would be a nice add on for Evernote! But … beyond having cards, I long for the ability to choose a selector on the canvas where all the cards are, and un-grid the cards from neat rows and columns, so I can drag the cards around and reorganize them. I’ve been contacted by several GTD system startups, a couple using cards like Trello. But it looks like manual card arranging + re-freezing cards into re-arranged columns and rows … is not in the cards at present. :-) No pun too low! Also, while I can use to create trello Card from NEW NOTES in evernote, migrating from Evernote to Trello wholesale, is not supported. Being an old person (55), I resist patching electronic systems together. Patching devolves into teaching pigs to sing way too often in my experience. This is not optimal, I resisted giving OneNote a serious try for way too long. But, I have a finite budget of IT investment energy and time, so I conserve.

  12. Bill, bravo to your meta-productivity awareness, chronicled here. Good and bad news-you’ve nailed how subtle the stress of opportunity of tools galore can be. Only if you “get” GTD can you have a north star amidst all this. If you don’t, well, good luck…! Thanks for your post.

    David Allen

  13. Pingback: OneNote vs. Evernote vs. Dropbox | RestartGTD

  14. Pingback: Dropbox … I’ve gotta go back … | RestartGTD

  15. Wow, what a great story and what great pictures to go along with it. Really helps bring it home!

    You seem to really like and be familiar with Omnifocus. We have built a web app for GTD that has some similarity to Omnifocus. When you get a chance, I’d love for you to take a look and le t me know what you think.

  16. Yeah, I was the worst of organizational sinners before reading GTD. Probably has something to do with why I “pay it forward” by writing the blog. No, actually, I GET MORE from writing the blog than it costs. I learn a lot by having to *reflect* on what was hard, what was easy, and how the evolution of a GTD system works. There are a few more before/after posts. High school engineering teacher’s desk is in Abomination of Deskolation … Redeemed!, my desk in detail and a student’s desk are in The Perfect GETTING THINGS DONE (GTD) Desk. My latest desk is in Dungeon Desk. And an accountant’s desk makeover in 3″x5″ Cards and Manila Folder GTD Startup.

  17. Holy crap! extreme makeover. Can’t argue with that! The before and after are pretty dramatic!

Comments are closed.